What Credentials and Local Experience Does the Agent Have?
Most residents want to be sure an agent truly understands the unique aspects of Stillwater’s housing stock, neighborhoods, and market trends. Ask agents directly about their professional licenses, years spent working in the immediate area, and their recent track record with homes similar to yours.
Experience in older homes, riverfront properties, or navigating historic districts can be especially relevant here. Verify whether they are familiar with common issues in local housing, such as bluffside erosion, older heating systems, or city-specific permit requirements.
How Familiar Is the Agent With the Stillwater, MN Housing Market?
Local expertise is critical for both buyers and sellers. Ask about their knowledge of area-specific pricing, recent comparable sales, and current inventory levels in different parts of the city.
An experienced agent should be able to answer:
- How typical sale timelines fluctuate through the seasons, especially considering Minnesota’s climate and school year cycles.
- Which neighborhoods have seen the most activity or price changes.
- Trends in the types of offers being accepted locally, whether cash, contingent, or first-time buyer programs.
What Services Are Provided—and Which Are Not?
Real estate agents vary in the range of services they offer. Before hiring, clarify what will be included, from staging consultations and professional photography to open houses and digital marketing.
For residents selling historic homes along local avenues, for example, ask whether agents provide guidance with disclosure requirements or have experience marketing properties with unique features that may need extra explanation to buyers.
If buying, inquire about support for property tours, virtual showings, negotiating inspection items, and help navigating local mortgage options or city permitting questions.
How Does the Agent Communicate, and How Often?
Consistent, clear communication is a top concern for most local households. Ask about the agent’s preferred methods—text, email, phone—and how often you can expect updates. For example, sellers may want immediate notice when buyers schedule showings, while buyers might appreciate quick answers about new listings that match their criteria.
Set expectations about response times and ask if you’ll be communicating with the agent directly, or if an assistant or team member will handle some updates.
What Is the Agent’s Approach to Pricing and Offers?
Pricing strategy impacts both buying and selling success in the community. Ask for a detailed explanation of how the agent arrives at listing prices or offer recommendations.
For sellers: Request a market analysis that specifically compares your home to others in Stillwater, not just broad regional data. If the agent suggests a price that seems high or low, ask for examples of similar homes and justification for the number.
For buyers: Find out how the agent helps you evaluate whether a property’s asking price fits current market conditions and recent sales in the city.
Can the Agent Provide References From Local Residents?
Asking for references helps gauge reputation and trustworthiness. Request recent feedback from other residents or area households they have helped sell or purchase a property. If possible, try to speak with people whose situations are similar to yours—such as first-time buyers, sellers of historic properties, or families relocating from another part of the state.

What Is Their Commission Structure and Are There Other Fees?
While commission rates are often negotiable, understand up front how compensation works and what it covers. Ask if there are separate charges for marketing, professional photography, or other services. Some agents may have different pricing for homes above certain price points, or adjust commission if you’re both buying and selling within Stillwater at the same time. Clarifying all costs in advance prevents confusion later on.
How Does the Agent Handle Multiple Offers and Negotiations?
In a competitive market, understanding your agent’s negotiation strategy is crucial. Sellers should ask how the agent manages multiple offers and what advice they provide for choosing the strongest buyer—not just the highest bid. Buyers can ask for examples of how the agent has helped others make compelling offers without overextending themselves. Inquire about creative solutions (escalation clauses, flexible closing dates, etc.) that are accepted in Stillwater transactions.
What Happens If You’re Not Satisfied?
It is reasonable to ask what recourse exists if the relationship isn’t working. Find out whether the agent allows you to end an agreement early without penalties, and what steps are involved. Request a copy of the agency contract up front and review it to confirm terms. Many area residents overlook this step, but knowing your options offers peace of mind—especially if circumstances change or expectations aren’t being met.
Are There Any Unique Considerations for Stillwater Properties?
Some Stillwater properties are subject to additional requirements due to location in the city’s historic districts, floodplains, or special zoning areas. Ask whether agents have direct experience handling disclosures, inspections, or city processes tied to these unique circumstances. For example, if selling near the St. Croix River, clarify knowledge of flood insurance rules or city-permitting for repairs. Historic homes may require special attention to lead paint disclosure and preservation requirements.
What’s the Agent’s Availability During Your Timeline?
Busy agents may juggle many clients at once. Confirm whether your agent is available during evenings, weekends, or times that fit your schedule, especially if you’re planning to move around the local school year or prepare for winter.
Ask if they are likely to take vacation or have times when their workload spikes, and who fills in if they’re unavailable. This can be important during the spring and fall, when area real estate activity is often highest.
About the Author
Olivia VanOrsdale
Olivia VanOrsdale is a Stillwater-born residential real estate professional serving the St. Croix River Valley and Twin Cities. With a background in strategic advertising, she offers a marketing-first, data-driven approach paired with calm guidance. Clients value her clear communication, organization, and thoughtful support throughout the process.
